Everyday American Customs That Look Superstitious Now—But Started For Practical Reasons

Everyday American Customs That Look Superstitious Now—But Started For Practical Reasons

Some Weird Habits Had A Point

Americans still follow plenty of little rules that sound strange when you say them out loud. Don't walk under ladders. Never open an umbrella inside. Knock on wood. And somehow we feel guilty when we spill salt. Today, they sound like old-fashioned superstitions. But some of these habits started for surprisingly practical reasons, and the real explanations are often stranger than the beliefs themselves.

1950s provoking bad luck woman wearing suit and hat carrying handbag walking under ladderDreamMedia, Getty Images

Advertisement

The Handshake Once Sent A Message

Today, offering your hand is simply a polite greeting. One longstanding explanation for the gesture is much more serious: an open right hand demonstrated that you were not holding a weapon. Ancient art shows handclasps being used to signal trust, alliances, and peaceful intentions thousands of years ago.

Professional business meeting with a handshake between consultant and client at an office.Kampus Production, Pexels

Advertisement

It Was A Quick Trust Test

The Smithsonian notes that handshakes in ancient Greek contexts could communicate peaceful intentions among armed men. Extending the right hand gave the other person a visible indication that it was empty. The familiar greeting therefore carried information before it became everyday etiquette.

Two businessmen smiling during a handshake in a modern office setting, symbolizing success and partnership.Edmond Dantes, Pexels

Advertisement

Americans Made It More Casual

The handshake did not always function as the routine greeting Americans know today. Some historians credit 17th-century Quakers with helping popularize it as a simpler and more egalitarian alternative to bowing or removing a hat. By the 19th century, American and European etiquette guides were already debating exactly how firmly people ought to shake.

A realtor finalizes a home sale with a handshake agreement, welcoming new homeowners to their property.Thirdman, Pexels

Advertisement

Walking Under Ladders Really Is Risky

Avoiding a ladder can look like classic superstition, especially when someone insists that passing underneath one brings bad luck. The supernatural explanations are disputed, but the practical danger is obvious. A person working overhead can drop a tool, while someone passing below can bump or destabilize the ladder itself.

Getty Images - 3142827 - 13th August 1948: This woman proves she is not superstitious by walking under a ladder in Fleet Street, London, on the unlucky day of Friday 13th.E. Brookes, Getty Images

Advertisement

The Ancient-Egypt Story Is Shaky

One popular explanation claims that a ladder leaning against a wall creates a sacred triangle and that ancient Egyptians considered walking through it offensive. That tidy story is repeated constantly, but historians have not found solid evidence connecting it directly to the modern superstition. Sometimes folklore acquires an impressive origin story long after the warning itself has become familiar.

Getty Images - 808127862 - After a lifetime - twenty-two years - of not walking under ladders and throwing salt over her shoulder, pretty girl singer Brenda Hudson is keeping her fingers crossed today, because Decca are releasing her first record I shouldn't Care About You Will Friday the Thirteenth be a lucky day for Brenda?PA Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

The Safety Rule Survived Anyway

The result is a useful warning wrapped in supernatural language. You do not have to believe in bad luck to decide that walking beneath someone working on a ladder is a poor idea. Generations could therefore preserve sensible behavior even as the explanation became increasingly mysterious.

Getty Images - 502325909 - Walking under a ladder on Yonge St. didn't appear to strike Finance Minister Marc Lalonde with premonitions of electoral disaster today as he indulged in a little main-street electioneering with colleague Jim Coutts; Liberal candidate in Spadina riding. Coutts steered a more prudent course.Boris Spremo, Getty Images

Advertisement

Indoor Umbrellas Were A Bad Idea

Opening an umbrella indoors still makes some people instinctively uncomfortable. There is a practical reason the rule makes sense regardless of superstition. Full-size umbrellas can knock into people, lamps, furniture, and other objects when suddenly opened inside a cramped room.

Shutterstock - 14820541 - Man Using Umbrella Indoor.George Dolgikh, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Older Umbrellas Could Be Awkward

The warning became especially understandable as spring-operated umbrellas became increasingly common during the 19th century. Early versions could be unwieldy, particularly when opened in a confined space. A rule discouraging people from snapping one open in the parlor did not require supernatural forces to be useful.

Shutterstock - 208286713 - Two businesswomen under an umbrella indoors.Stacey Newman, Shutterstock

Advertisement
F

History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.

Thank you!
Error, please try again.

Then Bad Luck Took Over

Folklore eventually supplied all sorts of supernatural explanations for the indoor-umbrella taboo. Records from the late 19th century already describe opening one inside the house as unlucky. Whatever produced the belief originally, the everyday rule also happens to protect faces, furniture, and anything fragile sitting nearby.

Shutterstock - 351874637 - Lovely expressive little girl sitting under an umbrella, indoor shot in white room.Alexandru Marian, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Driving On The Right Was Not Random

Americans driving on the right side of the road can seem arbitrary when compared with countries that drive on the left. But the habit was already taking shape before automobiles existed. The Federal Highway Administration points to large freight wagons, including Pennsylvania's Conestoga wagons, as an important influence on right-hand travel in the United States.

a group of cars driving down a road next to a lush green fieldJonathan Castaneda, Unsplash

Advertisement

Wagon Drivers Helped Set The Pattern

Drivers often controlled Conestoga wagons from the left side, sometimes riding the left rear horse or using a board mounted there. That position let them use their right hand to manage the team while keeping a better eye on oncoming traffic. By the time cars arrived, right-hand travel was already a well-established American road habit.

Title: A historic conestoga wagon
Abstract/medium: 1 photographic print.Ware Bros. Co., photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Saving Wedding Cake Once Made Sense

Freezing the top tier of a wedding cake for the first anniversary sounds like a sentimental modern ritual. But the tradition of saving part of the cake originally had a much more specific purpose. In 19th-century England, couples commonly kept some of their wedding cake for the christening of their first child.

DorigoDorigo, Pixabay

Advertisement

The Cakes Were Built To Last

These were not delicate modern cakes covered in soft fillings and fresh cream. Traditional wedding fruitcakes were dense and could be stored for long periods. That made preserving a tier considerably more practical when another family celebration was expected within the following year.

congerdesigncongerdesign, Pixabay

Advertisement

Refrigeration Changed The Meaning

The christening connection gradually faded, while the idea of keeping part of the cake survived. Modern couples are more likely to eat it on their first anniversary, often after freezing it. What now looks like a quirky piece of wedding luck began partly because the cake itself was durable enough to be reused at the family's next major event.

Giuseppe MacriGiuseppe Macri, Pexels

Advertisement

A Toast Once Involved Actual Toast

Raising a glass and proposing a toast has become so familiar that the word barely sounds strange. Yet the English term really is connected to toasted bread. By the 16th century, spiced toast could be placed in wine as part of drinking customs.

CordMediaDigitalServicesCordMediaDigitalServices, Pixabay

Advertisement

The Bread Could Improve The Drink

Accounts of the custom describe toasted or spiced bread being used with wine that could contain sediment or taste unpleasant. The bread could absorb impurities and alter the flavor. Over time, the word moved away from the bread and became associated with drinking in someone's honor.

Two pieces of Toast on a plate with a knife.Nachoman-au, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Poison Story Is Probably Wrong

There is also a much more dramatic explanation that refuses to disappear. It claims people began clinking glasses so liquid would splash between cups, proving nobody had poisoned another person's drink. Historians have found no credible evidence for that story, making it a good example of folklore replacing a less cinematic history.

Shutterstock - 618266228 - Christmas celebration. people toasting with champagne and wine glasses in hands clinking at luxury wedding reception at restaurant.Bogdan Sonjachnyj, Shutterstock

Advertisement

Sailors Thought Cats Brought Luck

Cats developed an extraordinary amount of maritime folklore. Sailors sometimes treated them as lucky mascots, with black cats receiving especially positive reputations in some seafaring traditions. Unlike many lucky charms, however, shipboard cats also performed an extremely useful job.

Lieutenant Commander R H Palmer OBE, RNVR plays with Peebles, the ship's cat, on board HMS WESTERN ISLES, Tobermory, Mull. According to the original caption, Peebles is very clever and shakes the hands of strangers when they enter the wardroom. Here he isMinistry of Information Photo Division Photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Rats Could Wreck A Voyage

Rodents consumed stored food and damaged ropes, wood, rubber, and other materials aboard ships. They could also contaminate supplies and contribute to disease problems. Cats were natural pest controllers, which gave crews a very practical reason to keep them aboard regardless of what anyone believed about luck.

A rat stowing away on a ship, carrying the plague further afield. Drawing by A.L. Tarter, 194-.Iconographic CollectionsKeywords: Albert Lloyd TarterFew, Wikimedia Commons

The Lucky Mascot Earned Its Keep

Ship's cats could become genuine members of the crew rather than decorative pets. Historical accounts describe naval vessels giving cats food, sleeping spaces, and considerable attention. A sailor might call the animal lucky, but a cat that protected food stores from rats did not need magic to improve life aboard ship.

Atlantic Conference August 1941: Churchill restrains 'Blackie' the cat, the mascot of HMS Prince of Wales, from joining USS McDougal, an American destroyer, while the ship's company stand to attention during the playing of the National Anthem.Horton (Capt), War Office official photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Spilling Salt Once Meant Wasting Something Valuable

Spilling salt remains one of the most familiar bad-luck superstitions. Historically, though, salt was far more important than the inexpensive table seasoning found in modern kitchens. It was essential for preserving food and could be a valuable household resource, so carelessly spilling it was a genuine waste.

Four salt shakers on a table with salt spilled from one of them.Jorge Royan, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Superstition Went Much Further

That practical concern does not fully explain the belief that spilled salt brings bad luck. And throwing another pinch over your shoulder obviously wastes more of it. That part belongs firmly to folklore, showing how a sensible dislike of waste could become wrapped in superstition over time.

نمایی از پودر نمک خوراکی یا سدیم‌کلرید.Mahdijiba, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Breaking Mirrors Was A Genuine Disaster

Breaking a mirror supposedly produces seven years of bad luck, a belief with roots going back thousands of years. Ancient Greek and Roman cultures attributed unusual significance to reflections, helping give damaged mirrors supernatural meaning. Later generations kept repeating the warning long after mirrors became ordinary household objects.

anaterateanaterate, Pixabay

Advertisement

Mirrors Were Also Worth Protecting

There was another perfectly sensible reason to dread hearing glass smash. Mirrors were once difficult and expensive objects to produce, so destroying one could represent a significant financial loss. The mystical explanation may be ancient, but treating a fragile and valuable mirror with extreme caution required no belief in curses.

Alphonse Mucha ontwierp dit Art Nouveau interieur in 1901 voor de juwelierszaak van Georges Fouquet aan de Rue Royale in Parijs. Het maakt nu onderdeel uit van de vaste collectie in Musée Carnavalet te Parijs.Mark de Nijs, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Knocking On Wood May Be Younger Than It Sounds

Knocking on wood feels so ancient that explanations often involve pagan tree spirits and forgotten gods. The problem is that historians do not agree on any such origin. Folklorist Steve Roud instead connected the modern British tradition to a 19th-century children's game in which touching wood made a player temporarily safe.

Oct. 26, 2015The White House from Washington, DC, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

A Playground Rule Became Protection From Fate

In games such as “Tiggy Touchwood,” reaching wood could literally protect a child from being tagged. Roud argued that this familiar idea of touching wood for protection later fed the expression adults still use when they do not want to tempt fate. Whether or not that explanation settles the question completely, it is better documented than the romantic claim that modern Americans are unknowingly asking ancient tree spirits for help.

Krijgertje.

Jongens, wie mij krijgen kan,
Die, zeg ik, is een knappe man;
Gij krijgt mij niet, o, neen, o, neen,
Geen is als ik, zoo vlug ter been.AnonymousUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Strange Habits Usually Have A Story

A lot of everyday customs survive long after people forget why they started. Some began as practical solutions, while others picked up layers of superstition over time. Either way, the next time you knock on wood or avoid walking under a ladder, there may be more history behind the habit than you think.

Shutterstock - 2178027769 - Knock on wood, culture, ward off bad luck.Parkin Srihawong, Shutterstock

Advertisement

You May Also Like: 

Ordinary Jobs From The 20th Century That Vanished Faster Than Anyone Expected

How Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Fell For The Cottingley Fairies Hoax

Historical Figures Who Accidentally Became Everyday Vocabulary

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13


More from Factinate

More from Factinate




Dear reader,


Want to tell us to write facts on a topic? We’re always looking for your input! Please reach out to us to let us know what you’re interested in reading. Your suggestions can be as general or specific as you like, from “Life” to “Compact Cars and Trucks” to “A Subspecies of Capybara Called Hydrochoerus Isthmius.” We’ll get our writers on it because we want to create articles on the topics you’re interested in. Please submit feedback to hello@factinate.com. Thanks for your time!


Do you question the accuracy of a fact you just read? At Factinate, we’re dedicated to getting things right. Our credibility is the turbo-charged engine of our success. We want our readers to trust us. Our editors are instructed to fact check thoroughly, including finding at least three references for each fact. However, despite our best efforts, we sometimes miss the mark. When we do, we depend on our loyal, helpful readers to point out how we can do better. Please let us know if a fact we’ve published is inaccurate (or even if you just suspect it’s inaccurate) by reaching out to us at hello@factinate.com. Thanks for your help!


Warmest regards,



The Factinate team




✕

Want to learn something new every day?

Join thousands of others and start your morning with our Fact Of The Day newsletter.

Thank you!

Error, please try again.
✕