Franklin Pierce’s presidency was one of the worst in American history. Elected in 1852, Pierce entered office at a time of deepening national divisions over slavery. His policies would only worsen these tensions, setting the stage for the Civil War. A litany of tragic personal losses, poor political instincts, and disastrous decisions, Pierce’s presidency was the pits.
A Tragic Beginning
Pierce’s term began under a cloud of personal tragedy. Weeks before his inauguration, his 11-year-old son Benjamin died in a horrific train accident while traveling with his parents. The boy was killed instantly, leaving Pierce and his wife Jane emotionally shattered. Jane retreated from public life, turning the White House into a somber, grieving household.
Internet Archive Book Images, Wikimedia Commons
A Northerner With Southern Sympathies
Despite being a New Englander, Pierce held strongly pro-Southern views on slavery. He believed he could ease sectional tensions by appeasing the South, putting him at odds with many of his Northern supporters. This alignment would later define his presidency, as he consistently put the interests of slaveholding states ahead of the growing abolitionist sentiment in the North.
The Kansas-Nebraska Act Debacle
Pierce’s biggest legislative blunder came in 1854 with the passage of the Kansas-Nebraska Act. This law, crafted by Senator Stephen Douglas, effectively overturned the Missouri Compromise by allowing settlers in these territories to decide for themselves whether to allow slavery, a principle known as “popular sovereignty.” The act outraged Northerners, ignited bloody conflict in Kansas, and led to the collapse of the Whig Party and the rise of the Republican Party.
Bleeding Kansas And National Chaos
The immediate aftermath of the Kansas-Nebraska Act was chaos. Pro-slavery and anti-slavery settlers flooded into Kansas, each side determined to control the territory’s future. The result was a violent conflict known as “Bleeding Kansas,” where mobs clashed, towns were sacked, and political violence became common. Pierce’s administration did little to stop the bloodshed, further alienating Northern voters.
The Bureau of Engraving and Printing, Wikimedia Commons
His Own Party Dumped Him
Pierce’s pro-Southern stance alienated even members of his own Democratic Party. Northern Democrats abandoned him, and by the end of his term, his political support had collapsed. He became the first sitting president to lose his party’s nomination for a second term, a humiliating rejection that underscored the depth of his unpopularity.
The Ostend Manifesto Scandal
Pierce’s foreign policy was controversial. In 1854, his administration attempted to secretly purchase Cuba from Spain, the idea being that it would become a new slave state. The plan, called the Ostend Manifesto, was leaked to the public, sparking outrage in the North and damaging his credibility. The episode fed the notion that Pierce was a puppet of the South.
Failing To Prevent Civil War
By the end of his term in 1857, Pierce had done little to address the growing sectional divide. His presidency is often blamed for inflaming tensions between North and South, pushing the nation closer to civil war. He left office a discredited figure, his reputation shattered by a combination of political missteps and personal grief.
Photoengraving after painting by M. Root, copyrighted by J.C. Tichenor., Wikimedia Commons
A Lonely, Bitter Retirement
Pierce’s post-presidential years were marked by loneliness and bitterness. His wife Jane died in 1863, while Pierce struggled with alcoholism and depression. His public support for the Confederacy during the Civil War further tarnished his legacy, earning him the lasting scorn of many Northerners.
A Legacy Of Failure
Today, historians rank Franklin Pierce as one of the worst US presidents. His failure to provide moral or political leadership in a time of national crisis is seen as a critical factor in the descent into civil war. While his personal tragedies evoke sympathy, his presidency stands as a lesson in what not to do when the clouds of civil war are gathering.
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
A President Forgotten By History
Unlike other 19th-century presidents whose legacies have been reconsidered, Pierce remains mostly forgotten, known more for his failures than his achievements. His presidency, overshadowed by the towering figures of Lincoln, serves as a footnote to the events that would consume and transform America in the years following.
You May Also Like:
Think You Know America? Answer These American History Questions To Find Out
Liberating Facts About Harriet Tubman, The American Emancipator
