A Good Ol’ Wild West Mystery
The American Wild West was a genuine place of lawlessness, but it was also a place of ambition, opportunity, and rigid codes of honor. Countless many men and women sought their fortunes on the frontier—but not all of their stories made it into the history books.
Even modern Wild West experts are still unearthing mysteries that were never truly solved, yet continue to shape the legacy of the American frontier.
The Victorio Peak Treasure
Since the 1930s, Victorio Peak in New Mexico has been linked to rumors of a hidden fortune. Some say Spanish explorers left it. Others insist it was an outlaw stash. Despite searches, no one has ever proved the treasure’s existence, leaving only a mystery behind.
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
The Disappearance Of Etta Place
Etta Place, the mysterious companion of the Sundance Kid, simply vanished after 1909. Her true name, origins, and fate were never discovered—even the famous Pinkerton detectives failed to trace her. Was she killed or did she reinvent herself as someone else? Nobody knows.
The Lost Adams Diggings
The story goes that in 1864, a group of men stumbled onto a gold-filled canyon and planned to come back. However, before they could return, an Apache attack scattered the group, and the location was forgotten. Ever since, countless seekers have hunted for the legendary “Lost Adams Diggings” without success.
Rennett Stowe, Wikimedia Commons
The Secret Burial Of Cochise
When Apache leader Cochise died in 1874, his people buried him somewhere in the rugged Dragoon Mountains. Then they kept the location a closely guarded secret, so much so that historians, treasure hunters, and other travelers have searched for it ever since to no avail.
Richard N Horne, Wikimedia Commons
The Wickenburg Massacre
In 1871, a stagecoach near Wickenburg, Arizona, was ambushed, leaving six passengers dead. Survivors accused Apaches, but others insisted white outlaws staged the attack. No culprits were ever confirmed. The truth of the massacre remains tangled in prejudice and violence.
Marine 69-71, Wikimedia Commons
Did Pat Garrett Really Kill Billy The Kid?
Pat Garrett became famous for gunning down Billy the Kid in 1881—or so the story goes. Almost immediately, rumors began that Billy escaped death. Decades later, a man named Brushy Bill Roberts even swore he was Billy himself. However, historians have been divided on the truth.
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
The Bodie Curse
The abandoned mining town of Bodie, California, has a reputation for bad luck. Visitors whisper of a curse: steal so much as a nail, and calamity follows. Returned relics arrive at the museum each year, mailed by guilt-stricken thieves who beg forgiveness.
PDPhoto.org, Wikimedia Commons
The Colorado Cannibal (Alferd Packer)
In 1874, prospector Alferd Packer staggered out of the Colorado mountains alone. His companions were dead, and he admitted to eating them to survive. Some said he murdered them for food, others believed it was desperation. The courts argued on this for 3 years.
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
Bigfoot Sightings In The Old West
Frontiersmen and Native Americans told unsettling stories of enormous, hairy creatures roaming the wilderness. They spoke of strange footprints, eerie cries, and figures glimpsed at the edge of campfires. Whether real encounters or just campfire tales, these early Bigfoot accounts still spark debate.
The Ghost Riders Of Devil’s Backbone
Since the 1860s, travelers in Texas have spoken of ghostly riders appearing on Devil’s Backbone ridge. People describe phantom horsemen racing along the trail, sometimes in full Confederate uniform. Locals even say you can still hear hoofbeats echoing across Ranch Road 32 at night.
Strange Town: Undead Live - Devil's Backbone Evidence by Strange Town
The Murder Of Belle Starr
Belle Starr, the infamous “Bandit Queen,” lived boldly among outlaws but met a violent end in 1889. Shot near her Oklahoma home, suspicion fell on family and lovers alike. Since her killer was never caught, it left her murder an unsolved frontier whodunit.
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
The Peralta Stones
In the Arizona desert, carved stones surfaced in the 1840s, supposedly maps to hidden gold. Some believe they lead straight to the Lost Dutchman’s mine. Others insist they’re clever fakes. No one knows if they’re genuine or hoaxes, but that doesn't stop them from fueling countless treasure hunts across the Superstition Mountains.
Latin Heart Reader, Wikimedia Commons
The Fate Of Jesse Evans
The gunslinger Jesse Evans carved his name into Lincoln County’s conflicts. Then, around 1882, he disappeared completely. Did he die in the desert, or reinvent himself under a new identity? No evidence has surfaced, leaving his final chapter unwritten.
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
The Disappearance Of Albert Jennings Fountain
In 1896, Judge Albert Jennings Fountain set out across the New Mexico desert with his young son. Neither of them returned. Their wagon was found abandoned; however, their bodies were never recovered. The suspected killers escaped justice, so the mystery remains steeped in politics and revenge.
James Blanchard, Wikimedia Commons
The Marfa Lights
Since the 1880s, people near Marfa, Texas, have seen glowing balls of light hovering over the desert. They drift, flicker, and sometimes split apart before disappearing. Ranchers and tourists all reported the same thing: strange lights moving across Mitchell Flat with no explanation.
Jon Hanson from Vienna, VA, USA, Wikimedia Commons
The Lost Breyfogle Mine
Charles Breyfogle discovered a glittering deposit of gold in Nevada during the 1860s. Before he could fully claim it, he fell ill, and the location slipped away. His death sealed the mystery, and the supposed mine became another phantom in the West’s long list of vanished treasures.
Jacob Breyfogle Lost Gold Mine ~ Lost Treasures and Gold Mines by James Fariello
Ben Sublett’s Secret Gold Mine
During the 1880s, Ben Sublett often returned from the desert with sacks of gold, but he refused to tell anyone where it came from. Though neighbors even tried following him, they never succeeded. And when he died, the location went with him.
Ben Sublett's Gold Mine, Part 2 ("Treasure" with Bill Burrud) by Sublett Family Association
The Martian Pilot Of Aurora
In 1897, townsfolk claimed a flying machine crashed into a windmill in Aurora, Texas. Inside was a small figure they called a “Martian.” They buried it in the local cemetery, and stories say the wreckage sparkled with strange, silvery metal.
Black Jack Ketchum’s Lost Treasures
In the 1890s, outlaw Black Jack Ketchum made his name by robbing trains across Arizona and New Mexico, seizing gold and loot along the way. After his execution in 1901, rumors spread of hidden stashes. None were ever recovered, but it still keeps treasure hunters searching in vain.
The Phantom Stagecoach Of Apache Junction
Locals in Apache Junction, Arizona, told of a stagecoach appearing long after stage lines had ended, and generations of travelers have repeated the tale of the same phantom coach. Witnesses said it rolled across the desert, pulled by ghostly horses, before vanishing into the night.
Pantano ghost town and stagecoach stop by Desert Walker
The Lost Dutchman’s Gold Mine
Legend says Jacob Waltz discovered a secret gold mine in Arizona’s Superstition Mountains. But after he died in 1891, the location was lost, and since then, several treasure hunters have died trying to find it.
History's Greatest Mysteries: The Curse of the Lost Dutchman's Mine (S5) by HISTORY
The Vanishing Of Clell Miller’s Body
After the failed Northfield, Minnesota bank raid in 1876, outlaw Clell Miller’s body was displayed in town. Then it vanished. Some said it was stolen, others whispered about secret burials. What remained certain was the crowd’s memory of seeing him stretched out dead.
I.E. Sumner, of Northfield, Wikimedia Commons
Who Killed Johnny Ringo?
Johnny Ringo’s body was discovered under a tree, with a revolver nearby. Authorities said suicide, yet many suspected enemies had caught up with him. Legends even tie his death to the infamous Earps and Doc Holliday.
The Fate Of The Outlaws
Most believe Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid met their end in Bolivia. But from the start, people doubted the story. Some claimed they returned to America in secret, living quietly for years. Letters, photographs, and rumors keep alive the idea that the Wild Bunch outlaws escaped their fate.
Elmer McCurdy’s Mummified Body
After outlaw Elmer McCurdy died in 1911, undertakers embalmed him so well that carnival owners bought his body and used it as a prop. For 65 years, he traveled fairs and freak shows until filmmakers stumbled upon him in the 1970s, still preserved.
Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons
