Dolores von Fürstenberg was a high society heiress who married her stepbrother—and after he died, she fell in love with his half-brother.

Dolores von Fürstenberg was a high society heiress who married her stepbrother—and after he died, she fell in love with his half-brother.

She Was Born Into Another World

Dolores Maria Agatha Wilhelmine Luise von Fürstenberg-Herdringen was born in Berlin in 1936, into a family that moved easily through European aristocratic circles. Her father was Franz-Egon von Fürstenberg-Herdringen, while her mother, Gloria, would become one of the most celebrated society figures of the mid-20th century. 

Before Dolores was even an adult, her family connections had already stretched across European nobility, international finance, and the fashionable jet set.

Patrick Guinness and his wife, socialite Dolores Guinness (née Baroness Dolores Maria von Fürstenberg-Herdringen) on their wedding day, Paris, France, October 22nd 1955. Daily Express/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Advertisement

Her Mother Was A Style Legend

Gloria Guinness was far more than a glamorous society hostess. She became a contributing editor at Harper's Bazaar and was eventually inducted into the International Best-Dressed List Hall of Fame. Designers including Balenciaga and Givenchy dressed her, and her reputation for elegance helped make the Guinness name synonymous with international high society.

 Gloria Guinness seated in her suite in the Waldorf Towers wearing a black wool Givenchy jacket bordered in black faille over a sleeveless dress with a black Balenciaga hat and diamond ring and lapel pin as well as pearls and diamond and pearl earrings; black round-toe pumps completed the dinner outfit (Guinness owned the exact same outifts in mauve and blue linen with a beige hatWWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Dolores Had Serious Competition

Growing up beside Gloria could easily have left Dolores permanently in her mother's shadow. Instead, Town & Country noted that Dolores eventually became a fashion figure in her own right, appearing in some of the era's most prestigious magazines. The resemblance between their public lives would become unmistakable as Dolores entered adulthood.

 Socialite Gloria Guinness prior to accepting the J.C. Penny award as the WWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Fashion Photographers Loved Her

Dolores was photographed by major names including Richard Avedon, Bert Stern, Cecil Beaton, and Henry Clarke. She appeared in Vogue, Harper's Bazaar, and Town & Country wearing designers such as Dior, Givenchy, Saint Laurent, and Balenciaga. Those images helped establish her as one of the recognizable society beauties of the 1950s and 1960s.

Sir Cecil Beaton, 1928 studio portrait (by Lafayette)Lafayette Ltd, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement
F

History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.

Thank you!
Error, please try again.

One Photograph Captured The Dynasty

In 1956, Henry Clarke photographed Dolores alongside her mother for French Vogue, with both women dressed in Balenciaga. The photograph is now held by the Palais Galliera, the fashion museum of the City of Paris. Its original caption explicitly identified Dolores as Mrs. Patrick Guinness, revealing that her already complicated marriage had begun the previous year.

Gloria Guinness seated in her suite in the Waldorf Towers wearing a black wool Givenchy jacket bordered in black faille over a sleeveless dress with a black Balenciaga hat and diamond ring and lapel pin as well as pearls and diamond and pearl earrings; black round-toe pumps completed the dinner outfit (Guinness owned the exact same outifts in mauve and blue linen with a beige hat)WWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Her Family Suddenly Changed

Gloria's romantic life reshaped Dolores's family in an extraordinary way. In 1951, Gloria married financier and socialite Loel Guinness, whose son from an earlier marriage was Patrick Benjamin Guinness. That marriage made Dolores and Patrick stepsiblings, even though they shared no biological parent.

Miss Lindy Guiness, 22, pictured with her Father, Mr Loel Guinness, the financier, on arrival at Westminster AbbeyPA Images, Getty Images

Advertisement

Then Dolores Married Her Stepbrother

In October 1955, 19-year-old Dolores married Patrick Guinness in Paris. Contemporary and later accounts explicitly described Patrick as her stepbrother because Dolores's mother was married to Patrick's father. It was an unusual family arrangement, but there was no blood relationship between the bride and groom.

Portrait of Countess Dolores von Furstenberg and her fiance Patrick Guinness, on a veranda in London, July 6th 1955Lee, Getty Images

Advertisement

The Family Tree Was Already Complicated

Patrick's mother was Joan Yarde-Buller, who had divorced Loel Guinness years before Gloria entered the family. Joan later married Prince Aly Khan and had another son, Prince Karim, born in Geneva in December 1936. Karim would eventually become Aga Khan IV, making him Patrick's maternal half-brother.

Prince Aly Khan with his bride, Joan Yarde-Buller (Princess Tajudaullah), and family members after their civil wedding ceremony in Paris, France, May 18th 1936. From left: Muhammad Aga Khan III; Prince Aly Khan; Prince Sadruddin Aga Khan, Aly Khan's brother; Joan Yarde-Buller; Princess Theresa, Aly Khan's mother; Princess Andrée Aga Khan, third wife of Aga Khan III.Bettmann, Getty Images

Advertisement

That Connection Would Matter Later

For the moment, however, Dolores's life revolved around Patrick. Their marriage placed her inside the wealthy Guinness family while preserving the glamorous European lifestyle she already knew. It also created the remarkable situation in which Gloria Guinness was simultaneously Dolores's mother and her husband's stepmother.

Socialite Gloria Guinness smoking prior to accepting the J.C. Penny award as the WWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Children Quickly Followed

Dolores and Patrick had three children together. Their daughter Maria Alexandra was born in 1956, their son Loel Patrick followed in 1957, and Victoria Christina was born in 1960. Their descendants would later connect the Guinness family with yet another famous dynasty, the Greek Niarchos family.

Greek millionaire Stavros Niarchos.Associated Press, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement
F

History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.

Thank you!
Error, please try again.

Society Could Not Get Enough Of Her

Marriage and motherhood did little to remove Dolores from fashion magazines. Town & Country described her as part of the uppermost level of the international jet set during the 1950s and 1960s. Her clothes, travels, and photographs helped turn a private aristocrat into a public symbol of postwar glamour.

Pacific Western Airlines Ltd. flight attendants, Edmonton, Alberta, 1960 
Provincial Archives of Alberta, WS.337.

From the Wells Photographic Studios fonds.Provincial Archives of Alberta, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

She Became A Fashion Authority Herself

Dolores ultimately joined her mother in the International Best-Dressed List Hall of Fame. Vanity Fair's historical roster records Gloria's induction in 1964 and Dolores's in 1970. Few mother-daughter pairs could claim a more formidable fashion pedigree.

Gloria Guinness and friends attend the fashion show to benefit the restoration of the Chateau of Versailles, five American designers matching talents with five French couturiers at the Versailles Palace on November 28, 1973 in Versailles, FranceFairchild Archive, Getty Images

Advertisement

Sardinia Became Their Playground

Patrick was not simply vacationing among the elite on Sardinia's northeastern coast. In March 1962, he was one of six founding members of the Consorzio Costa Smeralda, alongside Aga Khan IV and several other investors. Their organization sought to plan and regulate development of the area that became the Costa Smeralda.

Portrait of Karim Aga Khan IV in the 1960s.REPORTERS ASSOCIES, Getty Images

Advertisement

They Helped Build A Legend

The Costa Smeralda soon became one of Europe's most famous luxury destinations. Its developers envisioned carefully controlled hotels, villas, and infrastructure along roughly 55 kilometers of Sardinian coastline. Patrick therefore had a direct role in a project that would become closely associated with wealth, yachts, celebrities, and the international jet set.

Panoramic view of Costa SmeraldaAlistair Wettin, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dolores Fit Right In

Dolores became closely associated with the new resort world. Photographer Slim Aarons captured her on the Costa Smeralda in 1965, an image now distributed through Getty Images. With her fashion reputation and social connections, she embodied exactly the sophisticated international crowd the resort was beginning to attract.

Photographer Slim Aarons talks about his new book, WWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Patrick And Karim Were Partners Too

The relationship between Patrick and Aga Khan IV went beyond being half-brothers. Both men were founding members of the Costa Smeralda consortium in 1962. That shared investment placed the two branches of their complicated family in the middle of one of the era's most ambitious luxury tourism projects.

Karim Aga Khan in Nouakchott during the proclamation of Mauritania's independence on November 28, 1960.Keystone-France, Getty Images

Advertisement
F

History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.

Thank you!
Error, please try again.

Then Everything Changed

On October 5, 1965, Patrick Guinness was involved in a catastrophic automobile crash in Switzerland. Time reported that his custom-built Iso Rivolta struck a tree near Turtig after traveling at extremely high speed. Patrick died from his injuries at only 34 years old, leaving Dolores a widow with three young children.

Vintage sepia image of a couple standing in an old cemetery with tombstones.Emmanuel Codden, Pexels

Advertisement

The Press Noticed The Family Connection

Time's notice of Patrick's death did something remarkable for such a short obituary. It specifically pointed out that Dolores was not only Patrick's wife but also his stepsister, explaining that Gloria had married Patrick's father in 1951. The magazine also identified Patrick as the half-brother of Aga Khan IV, laying out the unusual family structure for its readers.

 Gloria GuinnessWWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Dolores Stayed Close To Sardinia

Patrick's death did not sever Dolores's connection with the Costa Smeralda. Later accounts continued to associate her with a home there, and archival photographs place her in the resort during the years surrounding Patrick's death. The island remained one of the key settings in the intertwined lives of Dolores and the Aga Khan.

Küste bei Baja Sardinia, Costa Smeralda (Sardinien)Hajotthu, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Her Brother-In-Law Was No Ordinary Man

By then, Karim Aga Khan had enormous responsibilities of his own. He had succeeded his grandfather in 1957, at just 20 years old, as the 49th hereditary Imam of the Shia Ismaili Muslims. He also became an international philanthropist and development leader while remaining an unmistakable figure in European high society.

Portrait of Karim Aga Khan wearing a traditional turban, October 6, 1967.REPORTERS ASSOCIES, Getty Images

Then Came The Rumors

Within months of Patrick's death, the British press was reporting an extraordinary possible development. In May 1966, the Sunday Express ran a story claiming that the Aga Khan had decided to marry Dolores, describing her as Patrick Guinness's widow. Whether every detail of the contemporary report was correct or not, it demonstrates that the relationship was being discussed publicly at the time.

Aga Khan IV, Karim Al Hussaini ShahReg Speller, Getty Images

Advertisement

A Friend Later Gave A Stronger Account

Years afterward, a more personal version of the story emerged through Etti Plesch, a prominent figure in the same international social world. Plesch's published memoir is cited in biographical accounts as stating that Dolores fell in love with Aga Khan IV after Patrick's death and hoped to marry him. That testimony gives the romance more substance than the anonymous society gossip that frequently surrounded jet-set figures, although it remains one participant's recollection.

Horse owner Etti Plesch wrapped up against the cold as she watches some of the horses in the December sales at Newmarket, England, November 30th 1964. Central Press, Getty Images

Advertisement
F

History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.

Thank you!
Error, please try again.

The Relationship Was Almost Impossibly Tangled

If Dolores and Karim had married, she would have wed two men connected through their mother, Joan Yarde-Buller. Patrick was Joan's son with Loel Guinness, while Karim was her son with Prince Aly Khan. Dolores had therefore married her stepbrother first and was later linked romantically with that husband's half-brother.

Prince Karim Aga Khan (C) flanked by his mother, Joan Yarde-Buller (R) and Isameli Leaders, during the ceremony enthroned him as forty-ninth Imam of Nizari Ismailis, following the death of his grandfather, the Aga Khan III-, Getty Images

Advertisement

But There Was No Wedding

Whatever hopes or discussions existed, Dolores and Aga Khan IV did not marry. In 1969, Karim married British former model Sarah Frances Croker Poole, who became Begum Salimah Aga Khan. The couple eventually divorced in 1995, and he later married Gabriele Renate Thyssen in 1998.

Salimah Aga Khan and Karim Aga Khan with their children Zahra Aga Khan and Rahim Aga Khan in Switzerland in 1971.PAT, Getty Images

Advertisement

Dolores Remained A Style Fixture

Dolores's public identity survived the personal upheaval. Town & Country placed her on its July 1970 cover wearing a Christian Dior scarf and Cadoro earrings, the same year she entered the Best-Dressed Hall of Fame. By then, her status no longer depended simply on being Gloria Guinness's daughter or Patrick Guinness's widow.

Gloria Guinness wearing a new Givenchy Midi after a luncheon at Restaurant Z on December 12, 1969 in New YorkWWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

Her Children Continued The Dynasty

Dolores and Patrick's children remained linked to prominent society families. London's National Portrait Gallery identifies Loel Patrick Guinness as Patrick's son and records his sisters Maria Alexandra and Victoria Christina alongside him in a 1967 Norman Parkinson portrait. Victoria later married Philip Niarchos, connecting Dolores's descendants with the family of Greek shipping magnate Stavros Niarchos.

Philip Niarchos and Carolina Herrera attend an event at the Dakota, an apartment building in New York City, on December 1, 1987.WWD, Getty Images

Advertisement

She Outlived The Jet Set Era

Dolores lived long enough to see the society in which she had become famous change dramatically. She died in Switzerland in 2012 at the age of 75, decades after the heyday of the glamorous European jet set. Yet surviving magazine covers, museum photographs, and Slim Aarons portraits still preserve the image that made her famous.

anaterateanaterate, Pixabay

Advertisement

Her Real Story Was Stranger Than Gossip

Dolores Guinness's life sounds almost too tangled to be real, but its essential relationships are documented. She did marry her stepbrother Patrick Guinness, and Patrick really was the maternal half-brother of Aga Khan IV. Contemporary press reports and later memoir evidence then connected Dolores romantically with the Aga Khan after Patrick's death, completing one of high society's most remarkable family stories.

Aga Khan IV, wearing a tweed jacket over a sweater with a shirt and tie, as he stands with his horse Zeddaan, United Kingdom, 18th March 1973David Cairns, Getty Images

Advertisement

You May Also Like:

The American Heiresses History Forgot

Gloria Guinness, The Socialite Spy

These Socialites Hid Sordid Secrets

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13


More from Factinate

More from Factinate




Dear reader,


Want to tell us to write facts on a topic? We’re always looking for your input! Please reach out to us to let us know what you’re interested in reading. Your suggestions can be as general or specific as you like, from “Life” to “Compact Cars and Trucks” to “A Subspecies of Capybara Called Hydrochoerus Isthmius.” We’ll get our writers on it because we want to create articles on the topics you’re interested in. Please submit feedback to hello@factinate.com. Thanks for your time!


Do you question the accuracy of a fact you just read? At Factinate, we’re dedicated to getting things right. Our credibility is the turbo-charged engine of our success. We want our readers to trust us. Our editors are instructed to fact check thoroughly, including finding at least three references for each fact. However, despite our best efforts, we sometimes miss the mark. When we do, we depend on our loyal, helpful readers to point out how we can do better. Please let us know if a fact we’ve published is inaccurate (or even if you just suspect it’s inaccurate) by reaching out to us at hello@factinate.com. Thanks for your help!


Warmest regards,



The Factinate team




Want to learn something new every day?

Join thousands of others and start your morning with our Fact Of The Day newsletter.

Thank you!

Error, please try again.