Canada's Polite Outlaw
Bill Miner spent much of his adult life robbing stagecoaches and trains, serving prison sentences, and trying to escape them. Yet the American criminal somehow became a beloved Western Canadian folk hero. Known as the "Gentleman Bandit," Miner brought the old-fashioned Wild West outlaw way of life into the 20th century.
His Name Wasn't Bill
The outlaw was born Ezra Allen Miner near Onondaga, Michigan, in 1846 or 1847. He was one of ten children. His father died when Miner was nine, leaving his mother Harriet to raise the family.
California Came Calling
In 1860, Harriet Miner headed west by wagon with her three youngest children and settled at Yankee Jims, a California mining camp. Bill apparently gave little indication of what was coming. Accounts of Miner's childhood and adolescence describe him as an exemplary young man.
He Joined The Army
The Civil War offered young Miner another possible path. In 1864, he enlisted as a private in the Union Army at Sacramento and began using the name William. Military life apparently didn't suit him. Within only about two months, Miner deserted, providing an early glimpse of his lifelong aversion to confinement.
His First Known Crime
Miner's first known criminal act wasn't a glamorous stagecoach holdup. Around age 18, he stole approximately $300 from an employer. Remarkably, the employer declined to prosecute because he liked the young man. The act of mercy did not inspire Miner to straighten himself out. Quite the opposite.
He Became A Robber
Soon afterward, Miner robbed the Placer County treasurer on a street in Placerville, stole horses and escaped to San Francisco. He then joined John Sinclair and robbed travelers around Stockton. The pair were eventually caught and convicted, beginning Miner's extraordinarily long relationship with California's prison system.
San Quentin Became Home
Miner and Sinclair received three-year sentences at San Quentin. It was only the beginning. After his release, Miner teamed up with outlaw "Alkali Jim" Harrington and robbed a stagecoach near San Andreas in 1871. Miner had discovered the crime that would define the first half of his outlaw career.
Escape Was Already Tempting
Miner, Harrington and Charlie Cooper took about $2,600 from a stagecoach before Miner and Harrington were captured. The prisoners obtained a knife and began sawing through their restraints. A jailer caught them before they could escape, and Miner returned to San Quentin with a ten-year sentence. But Miner's first encounters with San Quentin were more complicated than a single sentence. He entered the prison in April 1866, was released by court order that June, then returned in July on a five-year grand-larceny sentence, finally leaving in 1870.
Freedom Lasted Briefly
Released in July 1880 after roughly nine years, Miner headed toward Colorado to visit his sister. Along the way he met Arthur Pond, regaled him with outlaw stories and helped turn the young man into "Billy LeRoy." Miner and his new associates subsequently robbed stagecoaches around Colorado.
He Almost Settled Down
For a moment, another life seemed possible. Miner returned to Michigan using the name William A. Morgan, presented himself as a prosperous California mining man, and became engaged to 20-year-old Jennie Louise Willis. Three months later his money was disappearing, so Miner headed west promising to return. He never did.
Back To San Quentin
Back in California, Miner joined highway robbers and participated in another stagecoach holdup near Sonora. Wells Fargo detectives soon captured him. In December 1881, Miner returned to San Quentin carrying a 25-year sentence that would consume much of what remained of the 19th century.
Another Escape Went Wrong
Miner generally behaved well behind bars, but freedom remained irresistible. In 1892, he and cellmate Joe Marshall devised a way out of their cell. A guard learned of the plan and ambushed them. Marshall was killed by shotgun fire, while an unharmed Miner surrendered and remained imprisoned.
An Old Man Emerged
Miner finally left San Quentin in 1901, having spent more than 33 of his 54 years behind bars. The world outside had transformed. Stagecoaches were disappearing and railroads now connected the continent. Miner visited his sisters in Washington State and, remarkably, made another attempt at honest employment.
He Tried Going Straight
For approximately two years, Miner worked as superintendent of an oyster business. The later movie version of his life depicts him discovering train robbery after watching The Great Train Robbery (1903), but historians say that's fiction. Miner had learned about train holdups from experienced robbers while imprisoned.
Trains Replaced Stagecoaches
In September 1903, Miner and accomplices Guy Harshman and Charles Hoehn attempted to rob an Oregon Railroad & Navigation Company train near Portland. An express messenger opened fire, seriously wounding Harshman. Miner escaped, but Harshman eventually identified his partners, making Miner's return to ordinary life increasingly impossible.
Bill Entered Canada
With American authorities looking for him, Miner crossed into British Columbia. Using the alias George Edwards, he lived around Princeton and cultivated the appearance of a harmless older gentleman. He also reunited with former San Quentin inmate Jake Terry and became involved in smuggling around the international border.
George Edwards Was Popular
The supposedly respectable Edwards was well liked. One local girl later recalled wanting somewhere to skate, so Miner cleared a field, flooded it from a creek and allowed the water to freeze. Whether every charming Miner story is reliable is another question, but tales like this helped build his Canadian legend.
The Big Canadian Score
On September 10, 1904, Miner, Jake Terry and Shorty Dunn held up a Canadian Pacific Railway train near Mission Junction. They escaped with roughly $7,000 in cash and gold dust plus about $300,000 in bonds and securities. It was the CPR's first train robbery and made Miner notorious.
First In Canada?
Miner is frequently credited with committing Canada's first train robbery, but the claim requires qualification. A Great Western Railway train had been robbed in Ontario decades earlier, although historians debate whether that incident constituted a true armed train holdup. Miner's 1904 crime was unquestionably the CPR's first.
He Couldn't Stop
In 1905, Miner and Jake Terry were suspected of robbing a Great Northern train near Seattle. Reports put the haul as high as $36,000, although the railroad claimed a much smaller loss and the crime was never conclusively pinned on Miner. Even so, he soon returned to British Columbia for another robbery.
Fifteen Dollars And Pills
The May 1906 holdup near Ducks, east of Kamloops, became almost farcical. Miner, Shorty Dunn and Louis Colquhoun separated the wrong cars, leaving behind a safe containing $35,000 in gold and overlooking more than $40,000 in cash. Their haul amounted to $15.50 and some liver pills.
The Mounties Got Him
A huge manhunt followed. Royal North-West Mounted Police, railway police, special constables, Indigenous trackers, bloodhounds and American detectives joined the search. The authorities eventually cornered the gang near Douglas Lake. Dunn resisted and was shot in the leg. Miner, true to his later reputation, did not draw his weapon.
A Gentleman Bandit
Miner's quiet manner contrasted dramatically with his profession. He became known as the "Gentleman Bandit," and legend credited him with popularizing or even inventing "Hands up!" Historian John Boessenecker dismisses the invention claim, but Miner's reputation as an unusually courteous and soft-spoken robber proved much harder to kill.
Canada Loved Him
The trial in Kamloops became a sensation. Miner continued claiming he was George Edwards even when a San Quentin warden arrived to identify him. After his conviction and life sentence, crowds reportedly gathered at railway stations as Miner traveled toward the British Columbia Penitentiary in New Westminster. The criminal had become a celebrity.
Prison Couldn't Hold Him
Miner reportedly told the court, "No prison walls can hold me." In August 1907, after little more than a year in the penitentiary, he proved prophetic. Miner and three inmates tunneled beneath a board fence, obtained a ladder and scaled the penitentiary's 12-foot outer wall. Suspicions that officials or the CPR facilitated his escape did exist, although an official investigation did not establish any collusion.
Back To The States
Miner returned to the United States and eventually lived comfortably in Denver, reportedly spending money from earlier robberies. When the money ran out, he returned to Michigan in 1910, recruited young Charlie Hunter and headed south. Even in his sixties, the aging relic of the Wild West wasn't finished robbing trains.
Georgia Was His Undoing
Miner and his accomplices robbed a train near White Sulphur Springs, Georgia. The operation went badly, a manhunt followed, and all three were captured within four days. Miner received 20 years in the Georgia prison system, another formidable sentence for a man already well beyond the usual age of frontier outlaws.
Too Old For This
Even Georgia couldn't end his obsession with escape. Miner broke out in 1911, was recaptured, then escaped again in 1912. His second flight through difficult swamp country badly damaged his health. After being returned to custody, the aging bandit joked, "I guess I'm getting too old for this sort of thing."
The Gentleman Bandit Passes Away
Miner's health continued deteriorating. He died in the prison hospital at Milledgeville, Georgia, on September 2, 1913, aged 65 or 66 (depending on which birth date we accept). Newspapers across America reported his death. The teenager who had begun stealing in California had survived shootouts, manhunts, prisons and escapes long enough to become a living Wild West anachronism.
The Buried Loot
British Columbia still has tales of Miner treasure hidden around places such as Green Lake and 70 Mile House. Boessenecker is deeply skeptical. He argues that criminals generally spent their loot or recovered anything temporarily buried, and Miner eventually ran short of money. The treasure hunt remains much better folklore than investment strategy.
Canada Kept His Name
Miner's Canadian afterlife is remarkable. Mount Miner near Princeton was named for him, while the Billy Miner Alehouse in Maple Ridge celebrates its outlaw namesake. The Keg restaurant chain even serves its famous Billy Miner Pie, ensuring that an American train robber's name remains oddly familiar to Canadians ordering dessert.
Hollywood Made Him Lovable
Phillip Borsos transformed the legend into The Grey Fox (1982), starring Richard Farnsworth as Miner alongside Jackie Burroughs, Wayne Robson and Ken Pogue. The acclaimed Canadian Western won seven Genie Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director, while Farnsworth's gentle performance helped cement Miner as a sympathetic old-fashioned outlaw.
The Legend Beat Reality
Some of the best-known Miner stories aren't true. He wasn't actually nicknamed "The Grey Fox" during his lifetime, didn't invent "Hands up," and evidence for the Robin Hood image is shaky. What remains is fascinating enough: a prolific American criminal who became an unlikely Canadian folk hero simply by being clever, courteous and spectacularly persistent.
You May Also Like:
Frank James And The End Of The Wild West
Wild West Facts About James Bowie, The Defender Of The Alamo