The NFL’s Biggest Scandals


Is The NFL As Scandal-Ridden As Washington?

The NFL is America’s biggest sports organization, and by proxy of how much money is invested in its infrastructure, there’s a lot in the way of corruption and scandal. Just take a look at this list, which spans from personal misdeeds of players to grand moves of owners and commissioners. 

Deflategate

The New England Patriots dynasty was tarnished by a number of scandals. Chief amongst these was the 2015 accusation of Tom Brady deflating balls used by the rival Indianapolis Colts during a playoff game.

 Jeffrey Beall, Wikimedia Commons

Deflategate

The highlight of Deflategate, though, was a Ben Affleck appearance opposite sports journalist Bill Simmons. Looking and sounding inebriated, Patriots fan Affleck created some very entertaining television by going into rant mode about the scandal. 

 Wikimedia Commons

Spygate

The other big Patriots controversy was during 2007 when it was uncovered that the team had been breaking the rules of the game and videotaping the signals of opposing team’s coaches so they could figure out plays. It probably helped the team maintain a perfect 18-0 record that year.

 jmwests, Wikimedia Commons

Spygate

Head coach Bill Belichick, as well as the team, faced massive fines, but the ultimate karma came later. The team heartbreakingly lost the Super Bowl game that postseason, ruining their perfect streak. 

 Getty Images

1925 NFL Championship

The 1925 NFL Championship was highly controversial due to the league's rule of granting the title to the team with the best record. The Pottsville Maroons, who had the best record, were suspended for playing an unauthorized exhibition game that season. 

 Coemgenus at English Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons

1925 NFL Championship

Their rival, the Chicago Cardinals, played and won two additional games against weaker opponents, securing a better record and the championship. Pottsville supporters argued the suspension was unjust, and unfavorably went towards the Cardinals. 

 MediaNews Group/Reading Eagle, Getty Images

Rams In Los Angeles

The St Louis Rams had a strong legacy, including the years of the Kurt Warner & Marshall Faulk run, which resulted in a Super Bowl victory. That being said, owner Stan Kroenke had other plans.

 Fox Sports, Wikimedia Commons

Rams In Los Angeles

Despite Kroenke’s promise to keep the team in St Louis, he made plans for a Los Angeles relocation, which the city united against. But there was only so much he could do, and the team relocated in 2016. 

 Ric Tapia, Getty Images

Washington Misconduct

As if the team formerly known as the Washington Redskins couldn’t get into more trouble, a controversy arose in the summer of 2020 over misconduct allegations. It appeared that both cheerleaders and office workers had been the victims of a toxic workplace created by the team’s owners.

 All-Pro Reels from District of Columbia, USA, Wikimedia Commons

Washington Misconduct

Years of investigation and millions in fines later, a conclusion was reached that the allegations were very true. It represented a moment of needing to recognize the abuse of power in the NFL. 

 Tom Williams, Getty Images

1921 Championship

The 1921 NFL championship had disputed game results and scheduling issues. The Chicago Staleys claimed the title with a 9-1-1 record, while the Buffalo All-Americans, with a 9-1-2 record, argued they should have it based on their head-to-head performance.

 Unknown authorUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons

1921 Championship

The critical game between the two was ruled an exhibition match by the league, favoring Chicago, which Buffalo contested. The lack of clear league rules and the ensuing decision to award the championship to Chicago fueled ongoing debate over the legitimacy of the decision. 

 Carrite, Wikimedia Commons

Aaron Hernandez

Ah, yes, another New England Patriots scandal to recount. That being said, there’s no fun in summarizing the tragedy of the late Aaron Hernandez.

 Getty Images

Aaron Hernandez

With a conviction for homicide in 2015, Hernandez’s promising football career flamed out. He sadly took his own life while in prison two years later.  Getty Images

Ray Lewis

Baltimore Ravens legend Ray Lewis is considered by many to be the greatest linebacker in the history of the NFL. That being said, a scandal followed him for much of his career.

 Andy, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Ray Lewis

In 2000, Lewis was charged with murder after a fight outside an Atlanta nightclub resulted in the stabbing of two men, but the charges were dropped in exchange for his testimony against his friends, and he pleaded guilty to obstruction of justice. The next year, Lewis would be the MVP of the Super Bowl game.

 KIMBERLY SMITH, Getty Images

Ray Rice

Years later, another Baltimore Raven named Ray ran into trouble. His controversy, though, opened up a whole other conversation about the ethics of the NFL. 

 Keith Allison, Wikimedia Commons

Ray Rice

In 2014, Rice was caught on camera committing domestic violence against his fiancée. Initially, he only got a two-game suspension, but further public outrage led to him being ousted from the team altogether.

 Getty Images

OJ Simpson

Probably the most notorious football player of all time, OJ Simpson’s legacy would’ve been about being one of the most successful running backs of all time. Unfortunately, events in the 90s said otherwise.

 Wikimedia.Commons

OJ Simpson

The trial surrounding the demise of Simpson’s ex-wife became possibly the biggest media sensation of the 90s. Though he got off, the general consensus was that Simpson was guilty of the crime. 

 Ted Soqui, Getty Images

Michael Vick

Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick seemed to be on his way to becoming one of the NFL’s greats until a scandal sank his reputation in 2007, resulting in prison time. From there, he found himself bouncing around multiple teams, never claiming a Super Bowl ring.

 Getty Images

Michael Vick

Vick’s controversy was that he was found guilty of operating a dog fighting ring involving pitbulls. You may even remember there being a joke about it on 30 Rock

 The Washington Post, Getty Images

Vikings On A Boat

Maybe you remember the line Price uttered in Purple Rain about needing to “purify yourself in the waters of Lake Minnetonka”. Well, the 2005 Minnesota Vikings did maybe something slightly the opposite.

 Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Vikings On A Boat

The team got in trouble for having a raunchy rave on multiple houseboats in the waters of Lake Minnetonka. Hopefully, any children within the vicinity had their eyes covered. 

 August Schwerdfeger, Wikimedia Commons

Steroid Ban

A strict steroid ban was put into effect for the NFL in 1987. That being said, it’s not like players won’t find a way around performance-enhancing drug rules.

 Shutterstock

Steroid Ban

In 2015, an investigation revealed that superstar quarterback Peyton Manning had been a potential recipient of performance-enhancing drugs. While Manning was eventually cleared by the NFL of the claim, suspicions still arose. 

 Jeffrey Beall, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Take A Knee

2016 was a time of fraught politics in America, leading up to the inevitable election result. One player, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick, didn’t want to stay silent about it.

 Sanders175, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Take A Knee

Kaepernick generated much controversy when he took a knee during every performance of the national anthem in the 2016 season. He, in particular, was speaking out against the trend of police brutality. 

 Michael Zagaris, Getty Images

The Bounty

In 1989, a controversy emerged between the Philadelphia Eagles and Dallas Cowboys when Eagles coach Buddy Ryan was accused of putting a bounty on Cowboys kicker Luis Zendejas and quarterback Troy Aikman. The bounty was to genuinely injure them so they couldn’t play. 

 Mitchell Layton, Getty Images

The Bounty

The fans did their part, too—in the second game between the two teams that season, the Eagles fans pelted the Cowboys with snowballs and beer. They’re considered some of the league’s fiercest fans for a reason.

 George Gojkovich, Getty Images

Concussion

Being that football is the most intense and violent sport, it’s come into question how much care is taken of the players. Concussions, in particular, have been a sore spot for their long-term health.

 picture alliance, Getty Images

Concussion

In 2005, a pathologist found proof of chronic traumatic encephalopathy in hundreds of players’ brains. The NFL even made an effort to cover up his findings instead of addressing the issue directly. 

 Boston University Center for the Study of Traumatic Encephalopathy, Wikimedia Commons

Dated Team Names

Multiple sports teams have been cursed with unfortunate names. A running theme, in particular, has been team names that are derogatory towards indigenous people. 

 All-Pro Reels, Wikimedia Commons

Dated Team Names

The team name of the Washington Redskins had been considered particularly offensive. For that reason, the team name finally changed to the Commanders in 2020. 

 Fibonacci Blue, Wikimedia Commons

Botched Expansion

With no pick in the draft, initially, expansion teams had to settle for picking players from other teams that they didn’t want, whether it was veterans or rookies. This meant that new teams were at an instant disadvantage. 

 Focus On Sport, Getty Images

Botched Expansion

The 1976 Tampa Bay Buccaneers definitely suffered from this, having a perfectly imperfect inaugural season, winning zero games. Soon, the expansion draft had to be introduced to give them a chance.

 Focus On Sport, Getty Images

Bill Belichick 

His second appearance on this list, New England Patriots legend Bill Belichick, has been mired in a recent controversy regarding his personal life. It’s something involving a new relationship, to be specific.

 AlexanderJonesi, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Bill Belichick 

The 73-year-old Belichick has come under fire for dating a 24-year-old former cheerleader, Jordon Hudson. To be fair, they’ve been seeing each other since 2023, so maybe they do have enough in common to make conversation. 

 Jared C. Tilton, Getty Images

Free Agents

The NFL’s initial free agent system had controversy with players, to the point that there was a 1976 court case over it. The problem was that it gave the league’s commission ultimate say over compensation for signed players.

 SSG Teddy Wade, Wikimedia Commons

Free Agents

The rule persisted, leading to the 1987 players' strike and another lawsuit two years later. It wasn’t until 1992 that things were totally fixed. 

 Thomas from London, UK, Wikimedia Commons

You May Also Like: 

Scandals That Rocked The Sports World

The Greatest Sports Underdogs And Comebacks

Ranking The Best Quarterbacks Of All Time

Source: 1