Secretive Facts About Felicia Montealegre, The Woman Behind Leonard Bernstein

1. She Was More Than A Wife

In her lifetime, Felicia Montealegre became known mostly as composer and conductor  wife. However, with the new biopic Maestro, Montealegre has emerged as a compelling figure. Broadway star, political activist and fashion icon all describe Montealegre in her all too short life, but there’s so much more. Let’s lay out the facts on Felicia Montealegre and see this remarkable woman for who she really was.

Portrait of Felicia Montealegre Bernstein, publicity photo. - 1957

Unknown Author, Wikimedia Commons

2. She Wasn’t American

Felicia María Cohn Montealegre came into this world in San José, Costa Rica on February 6, 1922. Her mother was the Costa Rican Clemencia Montealegre and her father was Roy Cohn, an American mine executive relocated to Costa Rica. The Montealegre name had panache in Costa Rica, as her great grandfather had been one of the top politicians there.

But while they had a name, Montealegre was about to have her privileged life in Costa Rica abruptly uprooted.

Portrait of Felicia Montealegre, as Joan in Joan at the Stake - 1958

Carl Van Vechten, Wikimedia Commons

3. She Wanted To Be Somewhere Else

When Montealegre’s father got a transfer, the entire family packed up and moved to a new and challenging place. This was Santiago, Chile where mom tucked Montealegre and her two sisters safely away into a private Catholic British Convent school.

Even with the posh school, Chile was not where Montealegre wanted to be.

She had her sights set on a place where she could fulfill her destiny.

Screenshot of Felicia Montealegre looking sad - from Flowers From A Stranger  (1949)

CBS, Studio One - Flowers From A Stranger (1949)

4. She Needed A Way Out

Felicia was very clear from her adolescent years, she wanted to move to America and pursue her dream of becoming an actress. Unfortunately, her parents were not on board. They said that if she wanted to be an artist, she would have to be the proper kind—like a musician or painter.

 Montealegre listened to them and smiled sweetly, whileshe was scheming to find a way out.

Screenshot of Felicia Montealegre looking at side - from Studio One - Of Human Bondage  (1949)
CBS, Studio One - Of Human Bondage (1949)

5. She Had A Proposal

When she was 21, Montealegre told her parents she would move to America and study the piano. When they objected, she reminded them that they had a famous pianist friend in New York named Claudio Arrau and he could be her teacher.

Her parents could hardly say no, and off she went.

Little did her parents know, Montealegre had a completely different plan once she hit the Big Apple.

Screenshot of Felicia Montealegre (Carey Mulligan) talking with man - from Maestro (2023)

Amblin Entertainment, Maestro (2023)