Motown's Tragic Hero
Marvin Gaye is a name that echoes through time as the undisputed king of soul. His voice still haunts radios, playlists, and movie soundtracks, decades after his tragic end. But behind the smooth melodies and timeless hits lies a story few dare to tell. Because Marvin Gaye wasn’t just a musical genius—he was a man at war with himself. The story behind this legend is far darker than you might think.
1. He Suffered As A Child
Born in April 1939 in Washington DC, Marvin Gaye was the second of his parent’s four children. He also had two half-siblings, an elder brother from his mother’s previous marriage, and a half-brother from one of his father’s affairs. Although he developed an early appreciation for music as a young boy, his childhood haunted him for far darker reasons.
photo by-J. Edward Bailey, Wikimedia Commons
2. His Father Was Cruel
Gaye struggled growing up in his father’s home. His father, Marvin Gay Sr, was a violent and controlling man. He had endless rules that he expected his children to follow and took great pleasure in “disciplining” them when they broke these rules. Discipline could come from something as minor as putting a hairbrush out of place or being a minute late home from school. As a result, Gaye barely survived his childhood.
The cover art copyright is believed to belong to None., Wikimedia Commons
3. He Was Beaten
The excessive punishment would have been difficult enough. However, Gaye later explained that his father would prolong the beatings, drawing out the fear and anticipation of punishment. Gaye felt that at least some part of his father enjoyed the entire process. He once stated, “By the time I was twelve, there wasn't an inch on my body that hadn't been bruised and beaten by him”. Only one thing kept Gaye going.
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
4. His Mother Saved Him
His father’s actions had a lasting effect on Gaye, and it wasn’t just physical. It affected his psychology as well, leading to him ultimately learn to use aggression to get the love and attention he craved. In all the chaos, his mother was the only thing that kept things from going too far. Gaye stated, “If it wasn't for Mother, who was always there to console me and praise me for my singing, I think I would have been one of those child suicide cases you read about in the papers”.
The Washington Post, Getty Images
5. He Ran Away
In an attempt to get away from his father and disastrous home life, Gaye ran away from home at the age of 17 and enlisted with the Air Force. However, Gaye’s upbringing did not lend itself to the harsh and controlling realities of the forces. He could not stop himself from rebelling against the strict orders that his superiors put him under. Eventually, Gaye plead mental illness to gain an honorable discharge—though, not before he had some fun.
Afro Newspaper/Gado, Getty Images
6. He Had A Fascination
By the age of 17, Gaye had undergone far more emotional and physical damage than anyone of that age (or any age) should suffer. It undeniably affected him and his psyche. One way this manifested was with an obsession with what he called “love for sale”. During his time in the Air Force, Gaye lost his virginity to a “woman of the night”. It left a lasting impact upon him.
Afro Newspaper, Gado, Getty Images
7. He Loved And Hated It
In Gaye’s own words, he referred to his experience with “love for sale” as “freaky," saying it had a large impact on him. To him, through this experience (and the idea of “love for sale" in general), he saw “a world of pure [desire] where people turned off their minds and fed their lusts, no questions asked. The concept sickened me, but I also found it exciting”. Judging by how he lived his life after that, the new fascination defined his questionable relationship to desire and love for the rest of his life...
Donaldson Collection, Getty Images
8. He Sought Out Music
Music had been Gaye’s emotional salvation since he was a child. So as soon as he left the Air Force, music was what he turned to. He formed a group that performed in DC, and he started composing. It was also around this time that Gaye added the “e” to the end of his name, to avoid allegations about his sexuality and to distance himself from his father. Even with his new commitment to music, though, he didn't began seeing any real success until the early 1960s.
9. He Found An Escape
You'd be hard pressed to try to name a musician who hasn’t been connected to substances in one way or another, particularly in the 60s, 70s, and 80s. And when it came to substance use, Gaye didn't miss a beat. He smoked weed frequently in his early days; however, in the early 1960s, that habit took a huge upgrade when someone introduced him to coke. He would grow dependent on the substance, particularly whenever his mental health was at its lowest. In 1961, however, Gaye experienced a rare bright spot in his life...
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
10. He Met A Woman
Marvin Gaye was 21 when he first met Anna Ruby Gordy. Gaye was a staff drummer for Anna Records, and Gordy was co-owner of the label, along with her sister and Roquel Billy Davis. Gordy was 38. But the 17-year age difference did not hold Gaye back from flirting with Gordy, hoping to get her attention. It didn't stop Gordy from reciprocating the feelings either.
Donaldson Collection, Getty Images
11. She Inspired Him
Marvin Gaye and Anna Gordy spent two years together before marrying in June 1963. Their relationship was complex and difficult. At the start of their marriage, Gordy inspired Gaye to write songs such as “Pride and Joy”, because she was, in his words, “my pride and joy”. However, that feeling would not last long; while Gordy continued to inspire songs, they were not nearly as complimentary.
Donaldson Collection, Getty Images
12. His Relationship Was Complicated
Yet again, evidence of Gaye’s childhood started to appear within his marriage. The 17-year age gap originally gave Gordy the the upper hand, and she allegedly behaved abusively to Gaye, both physically and verbally. Reports of extramarital relationships on both sides added even more weight to an already crumbling foundation. According to some reports, those infidelities inspired Gaye's 1968 hit, “I Heard It Through the Grapevine”. Still, they carried on building their lives together, though not in the way you might expect.
13. He Had A Son
In November 1965, the couple welcomed their first (and only) child: a son that they named Marvin Gaye III. Despite Gaye’s difficult relationship with his father, he chose the name to “keep up with tradition”. Publicly, Gordy (who was 43 at the time), presented herself as pregnant leading up to the birth of the son. However, that was not the case. Marvin Gaye III’s true mother was Gordy’s 16-year-old niece, Denise Gordy.
14. His Son Was Someone Else’s
The story surrounding Marvin III’s adoption is a strange one. For years, Gaye and Gordie told everyone he was their biological son. Then n the late 90s, Denise Gordy admitted to being the boy's mother. In her words, “My aunt was unable to have children and I had one for her. It was as simple as that”. Denise had turned 16 six days before giving birth to Marvin III. And as you can imagine, rumors still swirl about the boy’s father...
15. He May Have Been The Father
To date, no one involved has ever stated that Marvin Gaye is the biological father of his adoptive son. However, no one has explicitly stated that he is not the father either. The implications are disturbing. At the time of the birth, Gaye was 26 years old—more than a decade the senior of the child's teenage mother. It is unlikely that we’ll ever discover the truth as most involved have passed. However, for a period of time, before rumors sunk in, Gaye was the picture of success, both personally and professionally.
Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
16. He Made Bonds
The early days of Gaye’s career saw him collaborating with other artists. He first saw success with Mary Wells and spent some time working with Smokey Robinson. Tammi Terrell, however, was the partnership that saw the most success. He released several top-ranking duets with Terrell between 1966 and 1967, including “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough”. However, this partnership had a tragic ending.
17. He Blamed Himself
Terrell and Gaye were performing in Farmville, Virginia when she passed out in Gaye’s arms. She was rushed to hospital where the doctors diagnosed her with a brain tumor that ultimately ended her touring career and her life. Gaye reportedly blamed himself for the tumor, and spiraled into a depression and increased dependency on coke. It was a hit Gaye struggled to come back from.
18. He Contemplated The End
The pressures of Terrell’s tumor and his failing marriage proved too much for Gaye’s fragile mental health. He reportedly attempted to end his life for the first known time in 1969. He intended to shoot himself with a pistol he’d purchased. However, his father-in-law, “Pops”, eventually managed to stop him from going through with the attempt. Unfortunately, this demon would continue to haunt Gaye.
Michael Ochs Archives, Gettyimages
19. He Was Controversial
In June 1970, Gaye felt inspired to compose a new song after witnessing brutality at an anti-conflict rally. The record label initially refused to release the resulting song, “What’s Going On,” as they feared it was too political and would alienate audiences. However, Gaye refused to record anything else until they released it. When they did, it reached Number 1 within a month. But as his career rose, his personal life floundered.
20. He Lost One Woman
By the 1970s, reports stated that Gaye had started fighting back when Gordy came at him. In 1972, they moved to Los Angeles; but they would not remain together for long. By the start of 1973, Gaye filed for separation from Gordy, and in March of that same year he was working on his album Let’s Get It On when he met Janis Hunter, the 17-year-old daughter of jazz musician Slim Gaillard.
21. He Moved On Quick
Hunter came to the recording studio with her mother, Barbara Hunter, putting her into the orbit of the then 34-year-old Gaye. Their affair came about quickly and rapidly. Hunter is credited as Gaye’s motivation for the creation of the Let’s Get It On album, and he wrote the composition of “If I Should Die Tonight” after their first date. Their relationship burned like fire.
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
22. He Had A Whirlwind Romance
Hunter and Gaye met at the start of 1973. By September 1974, their first child, a daughter named Nona Aisha was born. Only a year after that, Hunter gave birth to their second child, a son named Frankie Christian in November 1975. This second birth may have been the last straw for Gaye’s first wife, as Gordy filed for divorce that same month, kicking off a contentious divorce proceeding.
Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images
23. His Divorce Got Complicated
In November 1975, Gordy sued for a divorce that ultimately turned nasty. She claimed irreconcilable differences and pressed the courts to make Gaye pay child support. Gaye conceded, but by September 1976, authorities locked him up after missing several payments. The divorce dragged on for another half year until Gaye’s attorney put an end to things.
24. He Made A Deal
Gaye’s lawyer, Curtis Shaw, wanted to see an end to the divorce issues. Therefore, he convinced Gaye to come to a compromise with Gordy; Gordy would receive 50% of the royalties of Gaye’s next album. With that matter settled, Gaye and Gordy finalized their divorce. However, Gaye wasn’t quite done with Gordy yet—he still owed her an album.
25. He Committed To The Music
Given the terms, Gaye’s initial impulse was to phone the album in. After all, why should he try when half the earnings were going to his ex-wife? However, as he began working, he became entranced by the idea of creating an album for his ex-wife; he also felt he “owed the public [his] best effort”. What followed was a break in Gaye’s traditional form of creation.
Los Angeles Times, Wikimedia Commons
26. He Found A New Art
Typically, Gaye did not write his lyrics. However, Gaye entered the studio only weeks after he finalized his divorce, recording with only Art Stewart, a sound engineer. Gaye then did something strange. He would “mumble” over prerecorded tracks or his accompaniment. After three or four takes, the mumbling became lyrics. In this way, he created Here, My Dear.
27. His Life Got Complicated
As Gaye recorded Here, My Dear the rest of his life was in upheaval. Now freed from his first marriage, Gaye and Hunter married in October 1977. However, even there, there are mixed reports as to the motivations behind this move. There are allegations that Gaye’s motivations for this marriage related to an issue he was having with his taxes and the IRS. However, Hunter maintains a very different reason.
Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
28. He Reversed His Status
Hunter insists that the pair agreed to marry on the heels of surviving a bad car accident together. Regardless of their motivations, they married by 1977, and in a complete reversal from Gaye’s first marriage, Gaye was now 17 years older than his wife. It seemed Gaye was unable to avoid large age gaps in his marriages, as well as serious drama.
29. His Marriage Was Broken
Gaye’s relationship with Hunter was turbulent, to say the least. They had an open marriage, which was complicated by Hunter’s later claims that Gaye would occasionally pressure her into getting intimate with other men. Domestic fighting and addictions also added a dark layer to their relationship, and by 1978, they were already on very rocky ground.
30. He Faced Failure
By the end of 1978, both Gaye and Hunter could see the writing on the wall. Adding insult to injury, Here, My Dear, Gaye’s album about his first failed marriage, released in December 1978 to middling reviews. Many critics called it “bizarre” or “un-commercial”. This lack of success angered Gaye, though not nearly as much as the album angered Gordy.
Michael Ochs Archives, Getty Images
31. His Wife Almost Sued Him
Anna Gordy was not impressed with the album. The average sales cut into what Gaye owed her from the royalties. However, it was the content that Gordy really took offense to. She considered suing Gaye for invasion of privacy. However, in the end, she decided not to. Later in her life, she even came to appreciate the artistry of the album. Something, many people have done.
Donaldson Collection, Getty Images
32. He Was Misunderstood
Recent critics have seen the value in Here, My Dear. They appreciate the artistry, often touting it as a landmark in Gaye’s career. However, at the time, the initial response angered Gaye so much that he stopped promoting it. Motown also stopped promoting it by early 1979, right around the time that Hunter filed for separation from Gaye, leaving Gaye at a particularly low point in his life and career.
33. He Couldn’t Escape His Demons
Depression followed Gaye throughout his life. He had already contemplated ending his life once already. And following all of these problems, Gaye attempted again through a failed coke OD. In his words, “I'd given up...the problems were too big for me...I just wanted to be left alone and [fry] my brains on high-octane toot”. Fortunately, it wasn’t his time to go yet; he still had more to do. He also had more problems to deal with...
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
34. He Had Money Troubles
On top of everything else, Gaye was having difficulties with the IRS; in response, Gaye entered a period in which he avoided the United States for fear of consequences. He owed many back taxes he’d failed to pay. So he went on a European tour and then relocated to London when that tour had finished to avoid the consequences. And while he couldn't really run forever, he definitely tried...
35. He Ran Away
In 1981, Gaye relocated from London to Ostend, Belgium. He was encouraged to do so by Freddy Cousaert, a Belgian DJ and music promoter. During that time, Cousaert did something for Gaye that no one else could. Cousaert succeeded in keeping Gaye clean and away from his addictions for some time. Unfortunately, it didn't last.
36. He Fell Into Old Habits
Gaye’s dependency on coke only exasperated the mental health issues that had carried over from his difficult childhood. Although he managed to stay clean during his stay in Belgium, he promptly fell back into old habits when he returned to the US and started his Sexual Healing Tour in April 1983. And with the usual depression came something even more scary—intense paranoia.
37. He Couldn’t Shake The Paranoia
Paranoia gripped Gaye during this tour. Gaye’s paranoia convinced him that someone was out to get him. In response, he wore a bulletproof vest during the entire tour. He also was constantly surrounded by armed bodyguards. Although this specific paranoid thought ended with the tour, the tendency continued to grow, finding new ways to manifest itself within his life.
38. He Went Back Home
Gaye’s relationship with his father never improved. Despite a small truce in the early 70s, the two men’s relationship remained contentious. However, Gaye continued to dote upon his mother who’d long remained a constant in his life. When his mother had a surgery that she needed to recover from, Gaye moved into his parents’ house following the end of his tour to support her. That’s when the trouble started.
39. He Avoided His Father
Initially, Gaye’s father was not present, as he was away on a business trip. However, when his father returned home, the tensions between the two men continued to grow. They spent six months attempting to keep their distance from each other, but they couldn't totally avoid each other living in the same house. And when they did end up in the same room, sparks flew...
The Washington Post, Getty Images
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
40. He Gave An Unusual Gift
By the end of 1983, when Gaye gifted his father a Smith & Weston .38 for Christmas so he could protect himself, all those around Gaye agreed that he had retreated into himself. He was afraid of leaving his room. All he talked bout was the end of his life and the end of life in general. It was a situation that was impossible to maintain.
Ron Galella Collection, Getty Images
41. He Jumped From A Car
Gaye’s sister, Jeanne, maintains that Gaye made another attempt upon his life at the end of March 1984. He jumped out of a speeding sports car. Although Jeanne insists that Gaye intended to end his life through that means, he made it out of that situation with only minor bruising. This was the state of mind Gaye was in as March turned into April.
42. He Reached A Breaking Point
Gaye was living with his parents, and, by all reports, refusing to leave his room by this point. In the days leading up to his final confrontation, his parents were arguing about a missing insurance policy document. Things came to a boiling point on April 1, 1984. Marvin Sr shouted up the stairs to his wife, at which point Gaye yelled out of his room that if his father had something to say, he should do it in person. Things escalated from there.
43. He Antagonized His Father
Marvin Sr did not listen to Gaye’s request, at which point Gaye told his father not to come to his room. Marvin Sr responded by doing just that, racing up the stairs and attacking his wife verbally over the missing document. That’s when Gaye demanded his father leave his room. But when his father refused, Gaye shoved him out and started kicking him. It became the beginning of the end.
44. He Knew The Consequences
Again, it is Gaye’s sister Jeanne who recalls the state of things in the Gaye family at this time. By Jeanne’s words, Marvin Sr made it public knowledge that if any of his children “touched him” he would kill them. Many believe Gaye was perfectly aware of this as he continued to beat his father until his mother was sable to separate them and send Gaye back to his room. Perhaps, he wanted the very worst to happen...
45. He Met The End
Records state that this entire incident started at 12:30 pm. Only 8 minutes later, Marvin Sr came into Gaye’s room holding his Christmas gift from Gaye. Silently, he pointed the weapon at Gaye and shot him in the chest. Although autopsy reports state that the first shot did enough damage to end Gaye’s life, his father came closer and fired again.
Richard E. Aaron, Getty Images
History's most fascinating stories and darkest secrets, delivered to your inbox daily.
46. His Mother Broke Down
Gaye’s brother Frankie and his wife, Irene, lived in a guest house on the property. The shots and the screams of Gaye’s mother, Alberta, drew them outside. Frankie initially thought the first shot was a car backfiring. However, Alberta quickly came outside, falling into Irene’s arms crying, “He's shot Marvin”.
47. His Brother Found Him
Frankie then ran into the house, He avoided his father, who had gone into his bedroom and instead found Gaye bleeding out in his bedroom. Reportedly, when Frankie held him, Gaye stated, “I got what I wanted... I couldn't do it myself, so I had him do it... it's good, I ran my race, there's no more left in me”. Marvin Gaye passed that afternoon in his brother’s arms.
Afro Newspaper, Gado, Getty Images
48. His Father Took The Fall
Marvin Sr was detained for his wrongdoing. He claimed that he did not know the weapon was loaded, and that he’d been acting in self-defense. When asked if he loved his son, Marvin Sr reportedly replied in a soft voice, “Let's say I didn't dislike him”. He was ultimately charged with voluntary manslaughter. Gaye’s family insists the entire thing was by Gaye’s design.
49. He Knew What He Was Doing
Gaye’s siblings maintain that Gaye knew exactly what he was doing that day; he wanted his father to come after him. Jeanne stated Gaye “accomplished three things. He put himself out of his misery. He brought relief to Mother by finally getting her husband out of her life. And he punished Father, by making certain that the rest of his life would be miserable... my brother knew just what he was doing”.
50. He Left His Mark
Gaye’s life was undeniably troubled. If he had not been so talented, it is possible this tragic end could have happened much sooner. Following his passing, there was an outpouring of love, grief, and support, which has continued even to this day. Marvin Gaye was a troubled man. However, he was a powerful musician, and in the songs he created, that power lives on.
You May Also Like:
Everything You Didn't Know About Motown
This Soul Icon Never Got To See His Own Success
