Medieval Rulers Who Got Away With Terrible Things Because Their Enemies Were Worse. Did History Let Them Off Too Easy?

Medieval Rulers Who Got Away With Terrible Things Because Their Enemies Were Worse. Did History Let Them Off Too Easy?

History Loves Picking A Side

Medieval rulers rarely came with clean hands. Yet some emerged as heroes because the people standing against them became so notorious that their own violence, betrayals, confiscations, and political ruthlessness faded into the background.

Portrait of Sultan Saladin (Giovio Series), 1566-1568Heritage Images / Getty Images

Advertisement

Robert The Bruce Started With A Church Killing

Robert the Bruce is remembered as Scotland's great warrior king, but his road to the throne began with the killing of a political rival. In February 1306, Bruce met John Comyn at the Greyfriars church in Dumfries and attacked him there. Killing a rival in a sacred space was serious enough to contribute to Bruce's excommunication.

Robert I, King of Scotland.Isaac Taylor, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

He Also Destroyed His Scottish Rivals

Bruce's war was not simply Scotland against England. It was also a Scottish civil war in which the Comyn family and its allies opposed his claim to the crown. After defeating the Earl of Buchan in 1308, Bruce devastated Comyn territory so thoroughly that later tradition remembered the campaign as the “Herschip of Buchan.”

File:RoberttheBruce.jpgMaksim, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Edward I Made Bruce Look Like The Liberator

Bruce's reputation benefited enormously from the opponent on the other side of the border. Edward I invaded Scotland repeatedly, deposed John Balliol, took control of Scottish fortresses, and oversaw the brutal execution of William Wallace. Against the king later nicknamed the “Hammer of the Scots,” Bruce's own ruthless rise could be absorbed into a much cleaner national story about resistance and independence.

An image from a set of 8 extra-illustrated volumes of A tour in Wales by Thomas Pennant (1726-1798) that chronicle the three journeys he made through Wales between 1773 and 1776. These volumes are unique because they were compiled for Pennant's own librarThomas Pennant, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Henry II's Temper Had Deadly Consequences

Henry II was an enormously capable king whose legal reforms helped shape English common law. He was also volatile, controlling, and determined to force the English Church into a relationship that suited the Crown. His furious complaints about Thomas Becket were followed by four royal knights murdering the archbishop inside Canterbury Cathedral in 1170.

King Henry II of England as depicted in an engraving fromP. Vanderbanck and E. Lutterell, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Then His Own Family Became The Villains

Henry's sons repeatedly rebelled against him, sometimes with the support of their mother Eleanor of Aquitaine and foreign rulers. The future Richard I eventually joined Philip II of France against his father, while John secretly sided with the rebels during Henry's final crisis. Because John later acquired one of the worst reputations of any English king, Henry increasingly looked like the formidable patriarch betrayed by an awful son rather than the ruler whose own behavior had helped drive his family into revolt.

Eleanor of Aquitaine, queen consort of Henry II of England.J. W. Wright (see here), Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Henry IV Took A Crown That Was Not His

Henry Bolingbroke returned from exile in 1399 claiming that he merely wanted the inheritance Richard II had confiscated from him. Within months, Richard had been deposed and Henry had crowned himself Henry IV. The new king then faced years of rebellion because plenty of people remained unconvinced that his seizure of the throne was legitimate.

King Henry IV, by unknown artist. See source website for additional information.

This set of images was gathered by User:Dcoetzee from the National Portrait Gallery, London website using a special tool. All images in this batch have an unknown author, buanonymous , Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Richard II Made The Usurper Look Reasonable

Henry could benefit from the fact that Richard had become increasingly authoritarian before his fall. Richard exiled opponents, confiscated the Lancastrian inheritance, relied heavily on favorites, and took revenge against nobles who had challenged him. Henry's own regime later executed rebels including Archbishop Richard Scrope, but Richard's abuses made the original usurpation easier for generations of writers to rationalize.

King Richard II, by unknown artist, late 16th century. See source website for additional information.

This set of images was gathered by User:Dcoetzee from the National Portrait Gallery, London website using a special tool. All images in this batch have Unknown authorUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Henry VII Won By Killing A Villain

Henry Tudor's claim to the English throne was hardly overwhelming when he landed in Wales in 1485. His army defeated Richard III at Bosworth, and the dead king's already controversial seizure of the throne made Henry's victory easy to frame as liberation. The Tudors then had every incentive to ensure that Richard became the dark ending to one age and Henry the respectable beginning of another.

Portrait of Henry VII of England wearing a hat with a jewel and holding a red rose. Pendant of File:Portrait of Elizabeth of York Cultural Heritage Agency of the Netherlands Art Collection NK1427.jpg.Anonymous (England)Unknown author, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Henry Was Much Less Gentle Than That Story Suggests

Henry VII became increasingly obsessive about money and political security as his reign continued. He used bonds, recognizances, fines, and aggressive financial administration to keep nobles obedient and increase royal revenue. The system became sufficiently unpopular that Henry VIII arrested and eventually executed two of his father's most notorious financial agents, Edmund Dudley and Richard Empson.

Henry VII (1457-1509), King of England, Lord of Ireland (1485-1509)Not stated., Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Richard's Reputation Did Henry A Huge Favor

Richard III's disappearance into Shakespearean villainy made Tudor coercion look comparatively dull. Stories about murdered princes, usurpation, and deformity dominated the public imagination, while Henry's quieter methods involved account books, legal pressure, surveillance, and carefully calculated punishment. Richard became the memorable monster, leaving Henry's less theatrical authoritarianism far less prominent.

File:King Richard III from NPG (cropped).jpganonymous , Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Philip Augustus Expelled France's Jews

Philip II of France is remembered as the king who dramatically expanded Capetian power and defeated King John's coalition at Bouvines. Early in his reign, however, Philip imprisoned wealthy Jews for ransom and in 1182 expelled Jews from the royal domain while confiscating property. He later allowed Jewish communities to return when doing so became financially useful.

This painting belongs to the Portraits of Kings of France, a series of portraits commissioned between 1837 and 1838 by Louis Philippe I and painted by various artists for the Musée historique de Versailles.Louis-Félix Amiel, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

King John Was The Perfect Opponent

Philip's greatest English rival was John, whose own reputation became legendary for all the wrong reasons. John's loss of Normandy, conflict with his barons, association with his nephew Arthur's disappearance, and eventual acceptance of Magna Carta made him one of England's classic bad kings. That contrast helped Philip remain the victorious state-builder, while the uglier parts of his domestic rule rarely receive equal attention.

File:British School - King John - Google Art Project.jpgBritish School – School Details on Google Art Project, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Saladin's Mercy Had Limits

Saladin's capture of Jerusalem in 1187 became famous partly because he avoided repeating the enormous slaughter associated with the First Crusade's conquest of the city in 1099. Yet he could also be ruthlessly practical. After his victory at Hattin, captured Templar and Hospitaller knights were executed because he regarded the military orders as particularly dangerous opponents.

Portrait of Saladin, Sultan of Egypt and Syria, half-length, directed and looking to the left, bearded, wearing turban, right hand touching his beard; illustration to page 627 of Andre Thevet'sCopyfraud, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Crusaders Made Him Look Gentle

Saladin's enemies supplied even more brutal comparisons. During the Third Crusade, Richard I ordered the killing of more than 2,000 Muslim prisoners after negotiations following the capture of Acre broke down. Against memories of the 1099 sack of Jerusalem and Richard's mass execution at Acre, Saladin's carefully cultivated reputation for chivalry became especially powerful.

File:Richard coeur de lion.jpgMerry-Joseph Blondel, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Michael VIII Saved Byzantium By Betraying A Child

Michael VIII Palaiologos is remembered for restoring Byzantine rule to Constantinople in 1261 after nearly six decades of Latin control. The achievement came after he had risen to power as guardian and co-emperor to the young John IV Laskaris. Once Constantinople was secure, Michael ordered the boy blinded, removing him permanently as a rival for the throne.

Michael VIII PalaiologosUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons, Enhanced

Advertisement

The Fourth Crusade Made Michael A Restorer

Blinding an 11-year-old was controversial even by Byzantine political standards and helped get Michael excommunicated. Yet his enemies were associated with the Latin regime created after the Fourth Crusade had sacked Constantinople in 1204. Because Michael ended that hated occupation, his dynastic crime could sit awkwardly beside a much more triumphant image as the emperor who brought Constantinople back.

ConquestOf Constantinople By The Crusaders In 1204Loyset Liédet, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Alexander Nevsky Cooperated With The Mongols

Alexander Nevsky became famous for defeating Swedish forces and the German crusaders advancing from the west. His relationship with the Mongol rulers to the east was much more cooperative. In 1259, when Novgorod resisted a Mongol census connected with taxation, Alexander helped ensure that the census was completed rather than allowing the city to defy the Horde.

Prince Alexander Nevsky. Miniature from the Tsarskiy titulyarnik (Tsar's Book of Titles).Collective of Kremlin Armory artists, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Teutonic Knights Gave Him A Cleaner Story

Later Russian memory focused heavily on Alexander's western victories, especially the Battle on the Ice in 1242. The Teutonic Order and other Baltic crusaders were themselves expanding through warfare justified as religious conversion. Against an image of armored invaders pushing eastward, Alexander's much messier accommodation with Mongol power became easier to overlook.

Statues of Teutonic Knights on the grounds of Malbork Castle in Malbork, Poland.Schlaier, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Ivan III Crushed Novgorod's Independence

Ivan III is celebrated for greatly expanding Moscow and breaking the political dominance of the Golden Horde. His unification of Russian lands was hardly voluntary. Novgorod resisted Moscow's growing control, and Ivan answered with military force before finally ending the city's political independence in 1478.

Painting of Ivan IIISergeyev, P. G., Wikimedia Commons

The Horde Made Centralization Look Like Freedom

Ivan's confrontation with Khan Ahmed on the Ugra River in 1480 became symbolic of the end of Mongol political supremacy over Moscow. Generations of national history therefore celebrated him as the ruler who liberated Russia from the so-called Tatar yoke. That heroic framework made the destruction of rival Russian political traditions, especially Novgorod's, easier to treat as necessary unification.

File:Kivshenko Ivan III tears off the khans missive letter.jpgAleksey Kivshenko, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Mehmed II's Great Victory Came With A Sack

Mehmed II's conquest of Constantinople in 1453 was one of the defining events of the late Middle Ages. After Ottoman troops entered the city, residents were killed, captured, enslaved, and separated from their families during the sack. Mehmed later worked aggressively to repopulate and rebuild Constantinople, but the conquest itself involved enormous human suffering.

File:Bellini, Gentile - Sultan Mehmet II.jpgGentile Bellini, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Vlad The Impaler Was An Extraordinary Rival

One of Mehmed's most famous later opponents was Wallachian ruler Vlad III. Vlad used impalement on a terrifying scale and deliberately advertised his killings as psychological warfare against Ottoman forces. The spectacular cruelty attached to Vlad's reputation can make Mehmed seem like the conventional imperial statesman in their rivalry, even though Ottoman expansion under Mehmed involved executions, enslavement, forced resettlement, and hard military conquest.

File:Vlad Tepes 002.jpgAnonymousUnknown author, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Charles VII Let Joan Face Her Enemies Alone

Joan of Arc helped transform Charles VII from a deeply insecure claimant into a crowned French king. Yet when Burgundian forces captured Joan in 1430, Charles did not mount a successful effort to recover the woman who had become essential to his legitimacy. She was ultimately transferred to the English, tried, and executed in Rouen in 1431.

Charles VII of FranceEugene a, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The English Occupation Made Charles The Savior

Charles also strengthened taxation and built a more permanent royal military structure as his authority increased. Those changes expanded the power of the French monarchy as well as helping defeat English forces. Because his enemies represented foreign occupation during the final phase of the Hundred Years' War, Charles could emerge as the king who restored France while the harder edges of his state-building received less romantic attention.

File:Portrait de Charles VII, roi de France - Musée Condé.jpgAfter Jean Fouquet, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Louis XI Was Proudly Manipulative

Louis XI did not earn the nickname “Universal Spider” because people thought he was straightforward. He relied on espionage, secret negotiations, bribery, pressure, shifting alliances, and relentless manipulation of rivals. His expansion of royal authority came at the expense of major nobles who wanted to preserve their own political independence.

File:Unknown - Portrait of Louis XI in a golden chain - M.Ob.1624 - National Museum in Warsaw.jpganonymous , Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Charles The Bold Made Intrigue Look Moderate

Louis's great rival Charles the Bold supplied a useful contrast. Burgundian forces under Charles destroyed Dinant and later devastated Liège after repeated rebellions against Burgundian authority. Next to Charles's spectacular military punishments, Louis's preferred weapons of money, diplomacy, and conspiracy could almost look civilized.

Karl der Kühne von Burgund (1433-1477), hier noch als Graf von Charolais dargestellt. Auf dieses Original beziehen sich alle weiteren Darstellung Karls als Herzog von BurgundRogier van der Weyden, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Ferdinand III Conquered Cities, Not Empty Territory

Ferdinand III of Castile and León became a saint and one of the great heroes of the Christian Reconquista. His armies captured major Andalusian cities including Córdoba and Seville as Muslim power fragmented during the 13th century. Those victories also involved the transfer of land and political power away from existing Muslim communities.

Saint Ferdinand III of Castile.anonymous, Spanish School, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Seville's Population Paid For The Victory

After Ferdinand's long siege, Seville surrendered in 1248. Research on the conquest notes that the Muslim inhabitants were expelled, after which property was redistributed under Christian rule. Ferdinand's enemies, the Almohads, had themselves imposed harsh religious policies on Christians and Jews in their domains, helping later Christian memory cast conquest as deliverance rather than also a process of displacement.

Trascoro de la Catedral de Sevilla. Óleo sobre cobre. El mítico rey Axafat entrega las llaves de la ciudad a Fernando III, Francisco Pacheco (1634).José Luis Filpo Cabana, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Heroes Usually Get Better Editing

None of these rulers needs to be transformed into a secret villain, and their enemies were not uniformly worse in every respect. What matters is that historical memory thrives on contrast, allowing one side's violence to disappear whenever the other side provides a more memorable monster. Medieval politics rarely offered clean heroes, but later generations were remarkably good at creating them anyway.

A portrait from the Welsh Portrait Collection at the National Library of Wales. Depicted person:  Richard III of England – king of England from 1483 to 1485George Vertue, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

You May Also Like:

History's Most Unbelievable Screwups

Facts About Military Underdog Victories

Legendary Facts About Lost Cities

Sources:  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27


More from Factinate

More from Factinate




Dear reader,


Want to tell us to write facts on a topic? We’re always looking for your input! Please reach out to us to let us know what you’re interested in reading. Your suggestions can be as general or specific as you like, from “Life” to “Compact Cars and Trucks” to “A Subspecies of Capybara Called Hydrochoerus Isthmius.” We’ll get our writers on it because we want to create articles on the topics you’re interested in. Please submit feedback to hello@factinate.com. Thanks for your time!


Do you question the accuracy of a fact you just read? At Factinate, we’re dedicated to getting things right. Our credibility is the turbo-charged engine of our success. We want our readers to trust us. Our editors are instructed to fact check thoroughly, including finding at least three references for each fact. However, despite our best efforts, we sometimes miss the mark. When we do, we depend on our loyal, helpful readers to point out how we can do better. Please let us know if a fact we’ve published is inaccurate (or even if you just suspect it’s inaccurate) by reaching out to us at hello@factinate.com. Thanks for your help!


Warmest regards,



The Factinate team




✕